Mourning and Dancing: A Double Concerto

The Santa Barbara Symphony’s adventurous 2024-25 season comes to a close this weekend with another unusual entry, as the pair of concerts represent the first time the organization has booked a soloist – in this case the very estimable violinist Gil Shaham – to perform different repertoire in the Saturday and Sunday concert. The Grammy-decorated Shaham has previously played in town with programs produced by CAMA and UCSB Arts & Lectures, not to mention the Music Academy of the West blowout show at the Santa Barbara Bowl with the fellows-powered Festival orchestra. This time Shaham solos with our local professional symphony for Tchaikovsky’s Violin Concerto – a repertoire staple at the Granada of May 17. Shaham then returns the following afternoon with his violinist wife Adele Anthony to play paired pieces in Bach’s “Concerto for Two Violins” followed by the West Coast premiere of Avner Dorman’s “Double Concerto,” with both concerts concluded by Dvořák’s ever-popular “Symphony No. 8.”
The Santa Barbara Symphony co-commissioned Dorman’s work, which has previously been played only once before – by Shaham and Anthony with the Sejong Soloists at Carnegie Hall last month. The new work was created as a companion piece to Bach’s Baroque concerto, but also inspired by the Book of Ecclesiastes, which lends the work its title, “A Time to Mourn and a Time to Dance.”
“That idea developed as I was writing it, by what was happening in the world,” Dorman said over the phone from his New York home last weekend, referring to the October 7, 2023, Hamas terrorist invasion of Israel, the deadliest attack on Jews since the Holocaust. “It was obviously a difficult day for me and many other people around the world. As I wrote the concerto, I noticed that the music oscillated between two extremes, one very mournful and the other with rhythmic dance. I couldn’t put it together at first and kept wondering, What’s going on? How is my psyche doing these two things?”
It was after seeing a video of a memorial service for a family member who perished in the attack, where there was singing and dancing, that Dorman understood that the seemingly irreconcilable responses were each ways to deal with grief.

“There’s the experiencing it and letting it be as it is – but there is also moving the body and kind of shaking it off,” he said. “It was happening in the music subconsciously first, and then I connected the dots.”
The end result is a four-movement work that contrasts a lamenting style in the first and third movements with dance-like second and fourth movements. Riffing off the Bach work, while building as well from traditional Jewish scales and gestures, form the main motif.
“There are parts where it goes down a half step, and it kind of sounds like someone is sighing or crying, which is related to both Jewish prayers and the Western classical tradition. But the strongest connection to Bach is that I included fugues in all of the movements.”
Dorman’s fast movements employ different meters to emphasize different dances, including a rhythm that’s not symmetrical to represent a more ecstatic movement, he said. The work ends with an exuberant dance that lends an upbeat feel for the audience to take away.
“Actually, I wanted to leave myself feeling upbeat and with a future to look forward to,” Dorman said. “I think that’s why Ecclesiastes has it in that order. It’s a healthy way to come out of mourning.”
The composer said he was thrilled with the premiere last month, with Shaham and Anthony exceeding even his expectations in the performance.
“I know them well, so it was easy to imagine them playing it as I wrote,” he said. “I felt very free in what I could do, because of their abilities and their personalities. They played as if they’ve been performing it for 20 years. It was really beautiful and moving.”







You must be logged in to post a comment.