City Converts State Street to $96 Million Playground

By Jeff Harding   |   September 15, 2026

At a September 1 Santa Barbara City Council meeting, in a 6-1 vote, the Council approved the State Street Master Plan, which converts a once-thriving main street to a playground. I was surprised since the City has no money for this $96 million project.

The Master Plan, a 495-page report including appendices, was drafted by the third consultant the City had hired over the past 10 years. The total cost of the three consultants was $853,250.

The report is typical of these kinds of things in that it was padded with a lot of graphics and boilerplate. It integrated recommendations of the State Street Advisory Committee, an entity whose members are chosen by the City Council. Of its 15 members, consisting of urban planners, architects, nonprofit heads and Council Members Meagan Harmon, Mike Jordan and Kristen Sneddon, there was only one State Street property owner.

The idea that this report is an objective analysis of State Street’s problems and solutions is wrong. It is not a “what should we do” but rather “here’s how to do what the City Council wants,” which means the consultant’s report is a foregone conclusion. The master plan study gave the Council members exactly what they wanted and skipped doing a careful analysis of the reasons for the economic decline of a formerly thriving commercial corridor.

In essence, they will convert State Street to a mall and playground. They ignore the reality of State Street as the gateway to Santa Barbara, and they fail to address the causes of the street’s decline. The idea of reviving State Street as a playground ignores the experience of other cities with street malls, which have largely failed. Santa Monica’s once-touted Third Street Promenade is an exemplar of a failed street mall concept.

I have been following this issue since 2017 when Noozhawk kicked off its “Reimagine State Street” series. My database comprises 156 pages of planning history plus scores of files of data. I have written six articles on State Street over the years, all of which were ignored by the City. 

Much of what is proposed as “solutions” appears to be solutions in search of problems. The problems affecting State Street haven’t changed much over the years, COVID aside. The closing of the street, the continued lack of retail vitality, bureaucratic barriers and revolving door vacancies haven’t gone away. None of the Master Plan’s efforts will solve these problems, problems that were created by the City.

The report estimates the cost of the project at $96 million. This exorbitant cost was never mentioned before. One questions whether the cost-benefit of a $96 million redesign of State Street is worth it. 

The City doesn’t have the money, which is why I don’t think this plan will happen. City Council Member Wendy Santamaria acknowledged that the City can’t afford it but was confident that the City will finance the project from generous state and federal grants. The Master Plan spells out potential sources of funding for most of the project: federal and state grants, City bonds and local taxes. One questions these assumptions since we know that the state has serious financial issues. Ditto the feds, with rising debt-financed deficits ($2.1 trillion this fiscal year and growing).

The State Street project will be done in three phases and will take up to 10 years to complete. Phase 2 (years 4-6; 400-900 blocks) starts the construction with a new stormwater system (tearing up the street), repaving the street and curbs, expanding the sidewalks, installing retractable bollards for traffic control, etc., etc. Cost: $30 to $50 million. Phase 3 (years 7-10; 1000 to 1300 blocks): same construction, landscaping, plus, plus, plus. Cost: $20 to $30 million.

Council Member Eric Friedman said at the hearing, “I can almost guarantee you it’s not going to cost $100 million and be done in six years. It’s going to cost more, and it’s going to take longer.” He is right. Projects like this one have a history of cost and time overruns. One need only look to our freeway as proof.

This plan is a good example of how the planning process is done in Santa Barbara. “Public input” is cover for our council members, who need to showcase the appearance of vocal community endorsement – a politicized planning effort to placate their supporters. This plan is a candy store for special interests who think they are better planners than the people financially impacted by their sweet dreams; the businesses and property owners who were largely ignored.

Nothing in this report addresses the real problems of State Street, and the plan comes at a huge cost we cannot afford.  

 

You might also be interested in...

Advertisement